intermountain-legal-logo-white-newintermountain-legal-logo-white-newintermountain-legal-logo-white-newintermountain-legal-logo-white-new
  • Criminal Defense
    • Drug or Alcohol Related
      • DUI Charges
        • Alcohol Restricted Driver
        • Ignition Interlock Restricted Driver
        • Sobriety Tests
          • Field Sobriety Tests FSTS
          • Breath Tests Blood Tests
        • Automobile Homicide
        • DUI Drug Charges
      • Drug Charges
        • Drug Possession
          • Possession of Marijuana
          • Possession of Oxycontin
          • Possession of Paraphernalia
          • Possession of Methamphetamine
          • Cocaine
          • Ecstacy MDMA
      • DUI and Drunk Driving Defense
      • Medical Marijuana
      • Underage Drinking / Minor in Possession of Alcohol
      • Selling Alcohol to a Minor
    • Violent Crimes
      • Resulting in Death
        • Manslaughter
        • Negligent Homicide
        • Murder Homicide
      • Assault
      • Aggravated Assault
      • Robbery
      • Kidnapping
      • Reckless Endangerment
    • Domestic Violence
      • Utah Domestic Violence Laws
        • Threat Violence
        • Violation of a Protective Order
        • Violation of a no Contact Order
        • Interruption of a Communication Device
        • Domestic Violence in the Presence of a Child in Utah
      • Crimes Involving Children
        • Child Abuse
        • Custodial Interference
      • Domestic Violence Assault
      • Domestic Violence Criminal Mischief
      • Domestic Violence Criminal Trespass
    • Sex Crimes
      • Violent Sex Crimes
        • Sexual Assault
        • Sex Abuse
        • Rape
      • Other Sex Crimes
        • Statutory Rape
        • Prostitution
        • Sexual Solicitation
        • Lewdness
        • Voyeurism
    • Criminal Activity Defense
      • Misdemeanor Defense
        • Potential Harm or Harassment
          • Stalking
          • Electronic Communication Harassment
          • Disorderly Conduct
          • Utah Intoxication Attorney
        • Damage to Property
          • Graffiti Vandalism
          • Utah Criminal Mischief Attorney
          • Utah Criminal Trespass Lawyer
        • Serious Traffic Violations
        • Probation Violations
        • Gambling
      • Weapon Crimes
        • Gun & Weapons Charges
        • Possession of a Weapon or Firearm in an Airport
        • Discharge of a Firearm from a Vehicle
      • Conflicts with Police
        • Filing a False Police Report
        • Interference with Arresting Officer
        • False Information to a Police Officer
      • Juvenile Crimes
        • Utah Juvenile Court System
        • Juvenile Felony Charges
        • Contributing to the Delinquency of a Minor
    • Theft and Fraud
      • Theft
        • Retail Theft Shoplifting
        • Embezzlement
        • Burglary
        • Robbery
        • Theft of Services
      • Fraud
        • Identity Theft
        • Check Fraud
        • Credit Card Fraud
        • Investor Fraud
      • White Collar Crimes
    • Record Expungements
      • Reduction of Criminal Convictions
      • Expungement Eligibility
    • Professional License Defense
    • Felony Defense
    • Common Questions
  • Family Law
    • Divorce
      • Contested Divorce
      • Uncontested Divorce
      • Divorce Decree Modification
      • Post Divorce Enforcement
    • Custody
      • Custody & Paternity
      • Custody Modification
    • Child Support Modification
    • Alimony & Spousal Support
    • Visitation & Parent Time
    • Mediation
    • Protective Orders
      • Defending A Protective Order
    • Other Practice Areas
      • Domestic Violence
      • Grandparent Visitation
      • Guardianship
      • Adoption
    • Common Questions
  • Appeals
  • Our Winning Strategy
    • Recent Case Victories
    • Testimonials
    • Accolades
  • Our Attorneys
    • Steve K Burton
    • Justin S Pratt
    • Staci Visser
    • Matthew Bell
    • Mark LaRocco
  • About
    • Find Us on the Web
  • Contact
  • (801) 970-2800
Is There An App for That?
March 11, 2013
When Cold Cases Get Hot
March 14, 2013
March 11, 2013
Categories
  • Family Law
Tags
  • adoption
  • custody
  • parental rights
  • same sex parents
  • Utah adoption attorney
  • Utah custody attorney
  • Utah divorce attorney
  • visitation

Parenthood brings with it certain rights and responsibilities.  Biological parents have rights to care for their children and make decisions on behalf of their children.  Biological parents also have the obligation to support their children through childhood, and in some states, through the completion of college.

The rights and obligations of non-biological parental figures are far less clear.  As more states recognize same-sex marriage and domestic partnership, it is becoming increasingly important for states to clearly define parental relationships.  Courts have been presented with new legal issues relating to therelationships between biological parents and parental figures in child custody cases.

The Kansas Case

The state of Kansas recently sued a sperm donor for child support and hospital expenses for a child born to a same-sex couple.  The man answered a Craigslist ad for a sperm donor.  Prior to donating his sperm, the man signed an agreement severing his parental rights and obligations.  However, the procedure was done through an at-home insemination kit, rather than through a health care provider.  Under Kansas law, a sperm donor’s parental rights are severed only when the insemination procedure is performed through a licensed doctor.  The biological mother’s former partner, who has acted as a parent to the three year old child, has intervened in the child support case.  The state’s position may be at odds with a recent Kansas Supreme Court decision holding that the non-biological mother of children in a same-sex relationship can have the same parental rights as the biological mother.

The Florida Case

In another recent case, a Florida judge listed three individuals as parents on a child’s birth certificate.  After a same-sex couple made several unsuccessful and expensive attempts to become parents through fertility clinics, they asked a male friend to donate sperm for artificial insemination.  The parties did not enter into a written contract defining each person’s rights and responsibilities with regard to the child.  After the child was born, the man sought parental rights.  The parties settled the case after two years of litigation.  Pursuant to the parties’ agreement, all three parties were listed as parents on the child’s birth certificate.  The agreement was approved by the court as an adoption.  The biological mother retained sole custody, and the child was legally adopted by the biological mother’s same-sex partner.  The biological father’s parental rights were severed by the adoption, but he retained the right to visitation.

Utah Adoption Law

The Utah legislature has made it nearly impossible for two same-sex partners to be recognized as the legal parents of a child.  Utah does not recognize same-sex marriage or domestic partnership.  Surrogacy agreements are valid only if the intended parents are married.  If a married woman becomes pregnant through the assistance of a sperm donor, the woman’s husband has parental rights to the child.  However, no such right exists for a same-sex partner.   Utah law in fact prohibits the adoption of a child by a same-sex partner.  Only adults who are legally married or single adults who are not cohabitating are eligible to adopt.  However, as domestic laws continue to change throughout the nation, our courts will be required to tackle difficult new legal challenges.

Read more about the Kansas case at:

Yahoo News

San Francisco Chronicle

Huffington Post 

Read more about the Florida case at:

Reuters

Miami Herald

a Rafflecopter giveaway

Share
0

Related posts

May 1, 2020

How to Pick a Divorce Lawyer


Read more
November 15, 2018

Holiday Visitation & Parent-time


Read more
November 4, 2014

The cost of representing yourself in a divorce.


Read more

INTERMOUNTAIN LEGAL

Salt Lake City Office:

2159 S 700 E, Ste 240
Salt Lake City, UT 84106

Phone: 801-970-2800

Fax: 801-951-4901


Murray Office:

491 W 5300 S #117
Murray, UT 84123

Phone: 801-970-2800

Quicklinks:

Criminal Defense & DUI

Family Law & Divorce

Appeals

Personal Injury

Our Winning Strategy

Our Attorneys

Blog

© 2020 Intermountain Legal P.C. All Rights Reserved. Built by Incline Marketing