intermountain-legal-logo-white-newintermountain-legal-logo-white-newintermountain-legal-logo-white-newintermountain-legal-logo-white-new
  • Criminal Defense
    • Drug or Alcohol Related
      • DUI Charges
        • Alcohol Restricted Driver
        • Ignition Interlock Restricted Driver
        • Sobriety Tests
          • Field Sobriety Tests FSTS
          • Breath Tests Blood Tests
        • Automobile Homicide
        • DUI Drug Charges
      • Drug Charges
        • Drug Possession
          • Possession of Marijuana
          • Possession of Oxycontin
          • Possession of Paraphernalia
          • Possession of Methamphetamine
          • Cocaine
          • Ecstacy MDMA
      • DUI and Drunk Driving Defense
      • Medical Marijuana
      • Underage Drinking / Minor in Possession of Alcohol
      • Selling Alcohol to a Minor
    • Violent Crimes
      • Resulting in Death
        • Manslaughter
        • Negligent Homicide
        • Murder Homicide
      • Assault
      • Aggravated Assault
      • Robbery
      • Kidnapping
      • Reckless Endangerment
    • Domestic Violence
      • Utah Domestic Violence Laws
        • Threat Violence
        • Violation of a Protective Order
        • Violation of a no Contact Order
        • Interruption of a Communication Device
        • Domestic Violence in the Presence of a Child in Utah
      • Crimes Involving Children
        • Child Abuse
        • Custodial Interference
      • Domestic Violence Assault
      • Domestic Violence Criminal Mischief
      • Domestic Violence Criminal Trespass
    • Sex Crimes
      • Violent Sex Crimes
        • Sexual Assault
        • Sex Abuse
        • Rape
      • Other Sex Crimes
        • Statutory Rape
        • Prostitution
        • Sexual Solicitation
        • Lewdness
        • Voyeurism
    • Criminal Activity Defense
      • Misdemeanor Defense
        • Potential Harm or Harassment
          • Stalking
          • Electronic Communication Harassment
          • Disorderly Conduct
          • Utah Intoxication Attorney
        • Damage to Property
          • Graffiti Vandalism
          • Utah Criminal Mischief Attorney
          • Utah Criminal Trespass Lawyer
        • Serious Traffic Violations
        • Probation Violations
        • Gambling
      • Weapon Crimes
        • Gun & Weapons Charges
        • Possession of a Weapon or Firearm in an Airport
        • Discharge of a Firearm from a Vehicle
      • Conflicts with Police
        • Filing a False Police Report
        • Interference with Arresting Officer
        • False Information to a Police Officer
      • Juvenile Crimes
        • Utah Juvenile Court System
        • Juvenile Felony Charges
        • Contributing to the Delinquency of a Minor
    • Theft and Fraud
      • Theft
        • Retail Theft Shoplifting
        • Embezzlement
        • Burglary
        • Robbery
        • Theft of Services
      • Fraud
        • Identity Theft
        • Check Fraud
        • Credit Card Fraud
        • Investor Fraud
      • White Collar Crimes
    • Record Expungements
      • Reduction of Criminal Convictions
      • Expungement Eligibility
    • Professional License Defense
    • Felony Defense
    • Common Questions
  • Family Law
    • Divorce
      • Contested Divorce
      • Uncontested Divorce
      • Divorce Decree Modification
      • Post Divorce Enforcement
    • Custody
      • Custody & Paternity
      • Custody Modification
    • Child Support Modification
    • Alimony & Spousal Support
    • Visitation & Parent Time
    • Mediation
    • Protective Orders
      • Defending A Protective Order
    • Other Practice Areas
      • Domestic Violence
      • Grandparent Visitation
      • Guardianship
      • Adoption
    • Common Questions
  • Appeals
  • Our Winning Strategy
    • Recent Case Victories
    • Testimonials
    • Accolades
  • Our Attorneys
    • Steve K Burton
    • Justin S Pratt
    • Elly Hendriksen
    • Matthew Bell
    • Mark LaRocco
    • Jackie Reidelberger
    • Hayli Dickey
  • About
    • Find Us on the Web
  • Contact
  • (801) 970-2800
John Quas v Utah Board of Pardons
April 22, 2020
State of Utah v Brenda Christine White
April 22, 2020
April 22, 2020
Categories
  • Criminal Defense Past Cases
Tags

State Of Utah V. Douglas Anderson Lovell

2011 UT 36
Filed July 12, 2011

In his third direct appeal from his conviction for the aggravated murder of Joyce Yost, the defendant appealed the district court’s denial of his motion to withdraw his guilty plea. The Utah Supreme Court reversed, holding that a trial court’s failure to strictly comply with Utah Rule of Criminal Procedure 11(e) constitutes good cause to withdraw a guilty plea.

Mr. Lovell plead guilty to the murder of Joyce Yost. He then moved to withdraw his plea. The trial court held that his motion was untimely, and Mr. Lovell appealed to the Utah Supreme Court. The Supreme Court reversed and remanded the motion for consideration on the merits. After hearing the motion on the merits, the trail court ruled that Mr. Lovell did not have good cause to withdraw his plea, and Mr. Lovell again appealed to the Utah Supreme Court.

Utah Rule of Criminal Procedure 11(e) requires that a defendant be informed of all the rights he waives by pleading guilty. The Supreme Court held that Mr. Lovell could withdraw his guilty plea because the trial court did not strictly comply with this rule. The Supreme Court disagreed with the trial court’s ruling that although the right to the presumption of innocence and the right to a speedy, public trail were not mentioned anywhere in the plea colloquy or the plea statement, Mr. Lovell was informed of these rights by virtue of his personal experience with the criminal justice system and thus Rule 11(e) had been strictly complied with. Rather, the Supreme Court held that past trial experience cannot be used to support a finding that a defendant was made aware of every waived right. While rule 11(e) does not require that the judge personally address the defendant about each waived right, it does require that the judge assume the responsibility of determining that a defendant has been affirmatively advised about each of the rights. In keeping with this requirement, the Supreme Court held that describing the State’s burden of proof was insufficient to advise the defendant of his right to the presumption of innocence. Further, entering his guilty plea on the day jury selection was to have occurred was insufficient to inform Mr. Lovell of his right to a trial before an impartial jury. Finally, the fact that Mr. Lovell’s other court proceedings had been public was insufficient to assume that Mr. Lovell must have recognized that his trial would be public. Support for a finding that the defendant has been advised of each of his rights must be found in the record. While a variety of documents may be used to support such a finding, these documents must be incorporated into the record. The record must make it clearly evident that the defendant is actually aware of the right, not that there is a reasonable basis to believe that the defendant knows of the right.

The Supreme Court also held that harmless error review does not apply to a trial court’s failure to comply with Rule 11(e). Harm will be presumed and thus there is good cause to withdraw a guilty plea. The defendant is not required to show that “but for” the trial court’s error he would not have plead guilty. This ruling applies to guilty pleas entered following the Supreme Court’s decision in State v. Gibbons, 740 P.2d 1309 (Utah 1987), and before the current version of Utah Rule of Criminal Procedure 11(e) went into effect in 2005. The Supreme Court declined to retroactively apply the current 11(e) to Mr. Lovell because the new version of the rule constitutes a “clear break with the past.”

Share
0

Related posts

April 22, 2020

State of Utah v David S Nielsen


Read more
April 22, 2020

State of Utah v David E Epling


Read more
April 22, 2020

State of Utah v Chanzy Walker


Read more

INTERMOUNTAIN LEGAL

Salt Lake City Office:

2159 S 700 E, Ste 240
Salt Lake City, UT 84106

Phone: 801-970-2800

Fax: 801-951-4901


Murray Office:

491 W 5300 S #117
Murray, UT 84123

Phone: 801-970-2800

Quicklinks:

Criminal Defense & DUI

Family Law & Divorce

Appeals

Personal Injury

Our Winning Strategy

Our Attorneys

Blog

© 2021 Intermountain Legal P.C. All Rights Reserved. Built by Incline Marketing