intermountain-legal-logo-white-newintermountain-legal-logo-white-newintermountain-legal-logo-white-newintermountain-legal-logo-white-new
  • Criminal Defense
    • Drug or Alcohol Related
      • DUI Charges
        • Alcohol Restricted Driver
        • Ignition Interlock Restricted Driver
        • Sobriety Tests
          • Field Sobriety Tests FSTS
          • Breath Tests Blood Tests
        • Automobile Homicide
        • DUI Drug Charges
      • Drug Charges
        • Drug Possession
          • Possession of Marijuana
          • Possession of Oxycontin
          • Possession of Paraphernalia
          • Possession of Methamphetamine
          • Cocaine
          • Ecstacy MDMA
      • DUI and Drunk Driving Defense
      • Medical Marijuana
      • Underage Drinking / Minor in Possession of Alcohol
      • Selling Alcohol to a Minor
    • Violent Crimes
      • Resulting in Death
        • Manslaughter
        • Negligent Homicide
        • Murder Homicide
      • Assault
      • Aggravated Assault
      • Robbery
      • Kidnapping
      • Reckless Endangerment
    • Domestic Violence
      • Utah Domestic Violence Laws
        • Threat Violence
        • Violation of a Protective Order
        • Violation of a no Contact Order
        • Interruption of a Communication Device
        • Domestic Violence in the Presence of a Child in Utah
      • Crimes Involving Children
        • Child Abuse
        • Custodial Interference
      • Domestic Violence Assault
      • Domestic Violence Criminal Mischief
      • Domestic Violence Criminal Trespass
    • Sex Crimes
      • Violent Sex Crimes
        • Sexual Assault
        • Sex Abuse
        • Rape
      • Other Sex Crimes
        • Statutory Rape
        • Prostitution
        • Sexual Solicitation
        • Lewdness
        • Voyeurism
    • Criminal Activity Defense
      • Misdemeanor Defense
        • Potential Harm or Harassment
          • Stalking
          • Electronic Communication Harassment
          • Disorderly Conduct
          • Utah Intoxication Attorney
        • Damage to Property
          • Graffiti Vandalism
          • Utah Criminal Mischief Attorney
          • Utah Criminal Trespass Lawyer
        • Serious Traffic Violations
        • Probation Violations
        • Gambling
      • Weapon Crimes
        • Gun & Weapons Charges
        • Possession of a Weapon or Firearm in an Airport
        • Discharge of a Firearm from a Vehicle
      • Conflicts with Police
        • Filing a False Police Report
        • Interference with Arresting Officer
        • False Information to a Police Officer
      • Juvenile Crimes
        • Utah Juvenile Court System
        • Juvenile Felony Charges
        • Contributing to the Delinquency of a Minor
    • Theft and Fraud
      • Theft
        • Retail Theft Shoplifting
        • Embezzlement
        • Burglary
        • Robbery
        • Theft of Services
      • Fraud
        • Identity Theft
        • Check Fraud
        • Credit Card Fraud
        • Investor Fraud
      • White Collar Crimes
    • Record Expungements
      • Reduction of Criminal Convictions
      • Expungement Eligibility
    • Professional License Defense
    • Felony Defense
    • Common Questions
  • Family Law
    • Divorce
      • Contested Divorce
      • Uncontested Divorce
      • Divorce Decree Modification
      • Post Divorce Enforcement
    • Custody
      • Custody & Paternity
      • Custody Modification
    • Child Support Modification
    • Alimony & Spousal Support
    • Visitation & Parent Time
    • Mediation
    • Protective Orders
      • Defending A Protective Order
    • Other Practice Areas
      • Domestic Violence
      • Grandparent Visitation
      • Guardianship
      • Adoption
    • Common Questions
  • Appeals
  • Our Winning Strategy
    • Recent Case Victories
    • Testimonials
    • Accolades
  • Our Attorneys
    • Steve K Burton
    • Justin S Pratt
    • Elly Hendriksen
    • Matthew Bell
    • Mark LaRocco
    • Jackie Reidelberger
    • Hayli Dickey
  • About
    • Find Us on the Web
  • Contact
  • (801) 970-2800
State of Utah v Zachariah E Clark
April 22, 2020
Trovon Donta Ross v State of Utah
April 22, 2020
April 22, 2020
Categories
  • Criminal Defense Past Cases
Tags

Terry Johnson V. State Of Utah

2011 UT 59
Filed September 30, 2011

The Utah Supreme Court dismissed the petition for post-conviction relief of a man convicted of murder because his claims either should have been raised on direct appeal or were appropriately dismissed by the district court for lack of jurisdiction.

Terry Johnson was convicted of murdering his child’s baby-sitter in 2004. He was sentenced to five years to life. Mister Johnson’s criminal defense lawyer filed a motion for a new trial, alleging that evidence had been admitted in violation of the Utah Rules of Evidence. Mr. Johnson then obtained a new criminal defense attorney, who filed a supplemental motion for a new trial that alleged that Mr. Johnson’s trial lawyer had been ineffective. The trial court denied both of Mr. Johnson’s motions. Mr. Johnson and his new criminal defense attorney appealed his conviction to the Utah Court of Appeals. The Utah Court of Appeals considered each of Mr. Johnson’s claimed grounds for reversal, but ultimately affirmed his conviction. Mr. Johnson and his criminal defense lawyer then filed a petition for post-conviction relief in the Utah district court. The Utah district court dismissed all of Mr. Johnson’s claims. Mr. Johnson and his criminal defense attorney appealed the dismissal of his petition to the Utah Supreme Court.

The Utah Supreme Court affirmed the dismissal of Mr. Johnson’s petition. Under Utah’s Post-Conviction Remedies Act, ineffective assistance of counsel is grounds for post-conviction relief. However, in his petition, Mr. Johnson challenged the effectiveness of the criminal defense attorney who represented him at his murder trial. Since Mr. Johnson was represented by a different criminal defense lawyer on direct appeal, Mr. Johnson could have raised this claim as part of that direct appeal but he did not. His claim was therefore barred.

Two of Mr. Johnson’s other claims – erroneous admission of open ended jury instructions and sufficiency of the evidence to convict him at trial – had been adjudicated in the district court. These claims were likewise barred because Mr. Johnson did not raise them on direct appeal.

Finally, the Utah Supreme Court held that the Utah district court rightly dismissed Mr. Johnson’s remaining claims as frivolous. In those claims Mr. Johnson essentially asked the district court to review the decision made by the Utah Court of Appeals, which a district court does not have jurisdiction to do. Mr. Johnson’s remedy for his dissatisfaction with the Utah Court of Appeals’ decision was to petition the Utah Supreme Court for certiorari, which he had already done and which petition had been denied.

Share
0

Related posts

April 22, 2020

State of Utah v David S Nielsen


Read more
April 22, 2020

State of Utah v David E Epling


Read more
April 22, 2020

State of Utah v Chanzy Walker


Read more

INTERMOUNTAIN LEGAL

Salt Lake City Office:

2159 S 700 E, Ste 240
Salt Lake City, UT 84106

Phone: 801-970-2800

Fax: 801-951-4901


Murray Office:

491 W 5300 S #117
Murray, UT 84123

Phone: 801-970-2800

Quicklinks:

Criminal Defense & DUI

Family Law & Divorce

Appeals

Personal Injury

Our Winning Strategy

Our Attorneys

Blog

© 2021 Intermountain Legal P.C. All Rights Reserved. Built by Incline Marketing